Here in Williamsburg, BGA in Tampa was consistently bad mouthed by locals for years (for example, it's dirty, the staff is rude, it's in a crappy neighborhood). It always came off as a very distant second to Euroburg (local 'Burg pride, no doubt, played a role here).
But when I finally visited the park for the first time two years ago, I didn't encounter any of those complaints (well, crappy neighborhood aside), and other 'Burg residents have even admitted that they now like BGA (maybe not as much as Euroburg, but they admit that they had a good time in Tampa).