My son purchased a book entitled "Thrill Rides" published by Meredith Books, written by Mark Shulman. (Copyright date of 2007) On the cover it says: Top 10 Roller Coasters in America
I recognize everyone has the right to their own opinion and I realize opinions can vary. With that said, I opened the book with an open mind.
As with many roller coaster books, this one provides some history on coasters along with a high level explanation of the mechanics of a roller coaster. There are pictures of El Toro, Raptor, Wild Thing, Twisted Sister, Talon, X and many others in conjunction with the explanations. However, the meat of the book is the top 10 list which is:
10 - The Cyclone (Coney Island)
9 - The Beast
8 - Dueling Dragons
7 - Son Of Beast
6 - Millennium Force
5 - Superman Ride Of Steel (New England)
4 - Boulder Dash
3 - X
2 - Top Thrill Dragster
1 - Kingda Ka
With any top 10 list enthusiasts could argue about the ranking order and raise an eye brow about some of the selections. However, this list caused more than an eyebrow raising. I could not get past the fact that this list, created in the last year or so, would include Son Of Beast and exclude El Toro.
I believe my anger/disappointment/sadness stems from the fact that this is a published book. There will be people who read this book and think their experience on the Son Of Beast represents that of a top rated coaster. Others who read this book will not realize El Toro should be given recognition for its greatness.
If there is anyone who believes the Son Of Beast is a better coaster than El Toro, please help me understand why.
Please note: An address was provided on page 2 of the book for comments and suggestions 1716 Locust St., Des Moines, IA 50309-3023 or meredithbooks.com. I would encourage those that care to send a comment or two.