Hi! I just read this whole thread and brought my stick for dead horse beating...
And since this is a Forum on the Internet I would like to express my opinions as well. Here goes...
Is it just me or did Vikings22 thread title not sound "attacking"? And the silly sounding subtitle of "shhhhhh" also was that not some what attacking? It's no wonder it was construed that Robb was being overly defensive. If you start a thread with a title like that, do you not expect him to be on the defensive? This site and all of it's content are his so why wouldn't he defend it. People tend to be passionate and defensive about the things they really love. If you insult Kidtums or Elissa, do you expect him to just go "Oh well"? This site and all of it's content are the same. He puts waaaaaay to much time and effort into it to NOT be defensive.
Then you should know by know that Robb is the kind of guy who tells it like it is. I am also a loooooong time lurker who posts once in a blue moon and I admit that when I first started reading this site, Robb came off as a little rough but over time you realize that is the way he is. And I applaud and respect him for it. I have never met him in real life but I am sure there are many folks here who can tell you that is in fact how he is in real life too. He is a very successful person because of what he does and how he is as a person. I am not looking for kudos here, just stating the facts.
With that said, I too will defend his videos. The video is suburb (so much so that companies actually use them in their promotional info..see IAAPA) and the audio is genuine. The audio makes it real for me. Yes occasionally a curse word may come out but that's real life. I say great job and PLEASE keep doing it the way you are Robb!
The bottom line to this whole thread is that Vikinks22 could have offered his criticism is a manner that was not as attacking but was still effective. Criticism can be helpful, but only when offered up in a way that is not attacking. This whole 14 pages of responsive could have been trimmed down to just a couple replies if presented in the right way. The moral, think not only about what you say, but how you say it.