The only problem with the valedictorian I see is that there are always those super-anal kids who think 100 is not good enough for a grade on a project, and insist on making it pretty and printed out on special glossy paper, or turn in a permission slip for a field trip early, all so they can get their 115 or 120. I'm serious! So the content of my work can be better than their's, and my base grade can be better, but they essentially 'grub' for extra points by complaining to the teachers.
However, this is AISD's generally lousy teachers. There's SO much extra credit. I don't believe in extra credit. Maybe you should've been paying attention the first time! And what makes me angry is that there's extra credit for completely non-academic accomplishments, such as, previously mentioned, turning in a permission slip early, or having your project bound, etc.
Is it really fair for those kids to have a higher GPA for completely non-academic accomplishments?
It may not seem like a big problem, but in the schools I go to, it IS!