Well, these ballots don't force anybody to choose from a list. Its basically pick your 10 top wooden coaster, 10 top steel coasters and the you write in your selection for the different categories.
The Deadline is in Early July so a lot of new coasters don't get the votes the first year.
The Golden Tickets have been a big part of what makes AT successful, they use them to promote the publication and it helps bring in a lot of revenue each year, just look at the number of ads in any issue that announces the results.
Like em or not, they are overall a good representation of what 500 or so people are thinking. I know people are upset about the placement of Balder, but that just reflects the number of people who have ridden it who voted. If I was voting I would have a hard time voting for something I had not ridden.
I think Mitches pole is more accurate just because there is no limit on who votes so there is a lot more representation all around.
As long as I have seen awards or polls, I have seen people disagreeing.
Overall, I think AT does a very good job. You might not agree with the results, but it is what it is.
I think a TPR award would be a very good idea BTW.