Jump to content
  TPR Home | Parks | Twitter | Facebook | YouTube | Instagram 

The Official Mitch Hawker 2012 Wood Coaster Poll Thread!


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 322
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Here's mine:

Boulder Dash Lake Compounce CT y, n, 1

My Favorite Steel Anypark Anywhere ** y, y, 2 -Kawasemi @ Tobu Zoo

Phoenix Knoebel's PA y, n, 3

El Toro SFGAd NJ y, n, 4

Cyclone Lakeside CO y, y, 5

Boardwalk Bullet Kemah Boardwalk TX y, n, 6

The Beast Kings Island OH y, n, 7

Twister Knoebel's PA y, n, 8

Wild Mouse Luna Park-Sydney AU y, y, 8

Blue Streak Cedar Point OH y, n, 8

Thunderbolt SF New England MA y, n, 8

Mean Streak Cedar Point OH y, n, 9

Regina Tobu Zoo JP y, y, 9

Cyclone SF New England MA y, n 9

Cyclone Luna Park NY y, n, 10

Twister II Elitch Gardens CO y, n, 10

Wildcat Lake Compounce CT y, n 11

Edited by Big-M
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not always this late, but I just turned mine in yesterday. I actually filled it out early on and then held off so I could re-evaluate Roar West, which ended up keeping the same spot. Instead, I just performed a few tweaks here and there.

 

01. Boulder Dash

02. Coaster

03. The Voyage

04. Phoenix

05. Giant Dipper, SCBB

06. American Thunder

07. Timber Terror

08. El Toro

09. Tremors

10. Prowler

11. Hades

12. The Beast

13. Thunderhead

14. The Legend, HW

15. Cyclops

16. Tornado

17. HellCat, Timber Falls

18. Renegade

19. Lightning Racer, L

19. Lightning Racer, T

21. Comet, TGE

22. Wild One

23. Wooden Warrior

24. Yankee Cannonball

25. Cyclone, Luna Park

 

26. Racer, KI

27. Viper

28. Timber Wolf

29. Coaster Thrill Ride

30. Cornball Express

31. Great White

32. Boardwalk Bullet

33. Cyclone, SFNE

34. Thunderbolt, KW

35. The Grizzly, KD

36. Excalibur

37. Thunderbolt, SFNE

38. Blue Streak, CP

39. Cyclone, Lakeside

40. Twister, Knoebels

41. Raven

42. Ghostrider

43. Outlaw

44. Roar, SFDK

45. Racer, KW

46. Hell Cat, Clementon Lake

47. Zeus

48. Lost Coaster of Superstition Mountain

49. The Boss

50. Judge Roy Scream

51. Colossus

52. Screamin' Eagle

53. Rebel Yell

54. Great American Scream Machine

55. Cannon Ball

56. Le Monstre

57. Rolling Thunder

58. Gwazi - Lion

59. Thunder Road

60. Wildcat, HP

61. Roar, SFA

62. Jack Rabbit

63. Dragon Coaster

64. Timberhawk

65. Apocalypse

66. Twister II

67. Mean Streak

68. Rattler

69. Hoosier Hurricane

70. Georgia Cyclone

 

71. Comet, HP

72. High Roller

73. Thunderhawk

74. Wildcat, Lake Compounce

75. Hurler, Carowinds

76. Hurler, KD

77. Underground

78. American Eagle

79. The Grizzly, CGA

80. Sea Dragon

81. Woodstock Express, Carowinds

82. Ghoster Coaster, KD

83. Woodstock Express, KI

84. Pegasus

85. Little Dipper

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Before the results come out, I just wanted to talk about a few coasters I've seen discussed in this thread.

 

Roar East versus Roar West: I don't rank them too far apart, but rode both this year and find Roar West to be much better. I've ridden it on 5 occasions among the 2009 and 2012 seasons, and its ranking has held steady, at a current 44 out of 85, versus 61 for Roar East. Roar West is almost unbearable in the back, but has 2 or 3 decent pops of air in the front. Roar East didn't have much to offer at all and felt shorter than its sibling, though it's actually longer. I feared I might return to Roar West only to find it closer in experience to Roar East, but no; it's still clearly superior.

 

Jack Rabbit: Not a fan. I do like the charming, old school tunnel and the pleasant setting. The double dip is decent and surprising, but not life-altering. (Yes, I rode in the back row, hands up.) I much prefer the singular extreme drops on Cyclops and Coaster Thrill Ride, or the many strong pops on rides like Coaster, SCBB Dipper, and Phoenix.

 

Best GCI: Of course, the poll itself will give some insight, but there are also some threads for this topic, best GCI and GCI with the most airtime. (Only pointing this out because I find them interesting myself.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Robb, I think you and I may be among very few on the China trip who ranked both Fireball and the Dauling Dragons above Wood Coaster. In fact, we ranked all four coasters pretty similarly. But I think the GG coasters were a bit too rough for most people to rank as highly as we did. I liked Wood Coaster a lot, but it needed just a bit more "oomph" to make my top 20. But GCII coasters are always crowd pleasers, and Wood Coasters was one of the best of them.

 

Well, apaprently I was wrong.

 

If my sneaky sneak peek of the results is correct, then both of the Dauling Dragons ranked in the top 10, above Wood Coaster. Fireball, while just outside the top 10, beat out Wood Coaster as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's here!

 

1 El Toro SFGAd NJ 297 167 0 0 1.0000

2 T Express Everland KR 19 164 1 1 0.9910

3 The Voyage Holiday World IN 202 164 3 0 0.9820 57

4 Boulder Dash Lake Compounce CT 174 164 3 0 0.9820 52

5 Phoenix Knoebel's PA 242 163 4 0 0.9760

6 Balder Liseberg SE 86 160 5 1 0.9669

 

7 Dauling Dragon-L Happy Valley CN 11 155 7 3 0.9485 4

8 Ravine Flyer II Waldameer PA 145 158 8 1 0.9491 3

9 Dauling Dragon-R Happy Valley CN 11 154 8 3 0.9424

10 Colossos Heide Park DE 122 156 9 2 0.9401

11 Fireball Happy Valley Song CN 18 155 11 0 0.9337

12 El Toro Freizeitpark Plohn DE 35 153 11 1 0.9303

13 Troy Toverland NL 120 154 12 0 0.9277

14 Wood Coaster Knight Valley CN 11 146 7 10 0.9264

 

15 Thunderhead Dollywood TN 184 152 14 1 0.9132

16 Twister Grona Lund SE 39 149 15 2 0.9036

17 Prowler Worlds of Fun MO 88 149 16 2 0.8982

 

18 Thunderbird PowerPark FI 34 147 19 0 0.8855

19 Renegade Valleyfair! MN 78 147 20 0 0.8802

20 Tremors Silverwood ID 39 143 18 5 0.8765

21 Rampage Alabama Adventure AL 49 144 20 3 0.8713

22 Wodan TimburCoaster Europa Park DE 108 140 19 6 0.8667

23 Wooden Warrior Quassy CT 84 142 22 3 0.8593 29

24 Raven Holiday World IN 206 143 23 1 0.8593 29

25 Shivering Timbers Michigan's Adventure MI 106 142 23 2 0.8563

26 Zippin Pippin Bay Beach WI 22 130 21 4 0.8516

27 Kentucky Rumbler Beech Bend KY 89 141 24 2 0.8503

28 Coaster Playland BC 30 138 23 6 0.8443

29 Hades Mount Olympus WI 119 140 26 1 0.8413

30 HellCat Timber Falls WI 100 137 26 4 0.8323

31 American Thunder Six Flags St Louis MO 93 137 29 1 0.8234

 

32 Tonnerre de Zeus Parc Asterix FR 130 132 30 5 0.8054 21

33 Apocalypse S. F. Magic Mountain CA 160 134 32 1 0.8054 20

34 Comet Great Escape NY 110 133 32 2 0.8024

35 Lightning Racer - L Hersheypark PA 281 133 33 1 0.7994

36 Joris en de Draak W de Efteling NL 121 130 33 3 0.7922

37 Megafobia Oakwood UK 69 131 35 1 0.7874

38 New Mexico Rattler Cliff's NM 26 126 31 10 0.7844 10

39 Lightning Racer - T Hersheypark PA 282 130 35 2 0.7844 10

40 Joris en de Draak V de Efteling NL 120 129 35 2 0.7831

41 The Legend Holiday World IN 204 130 37 0 0.7784

 

42 Cornball Express Indiana Beach IN 129 126 40 1 0.7575

 

43 Timber Terror Silverwood ID 40 123 41 2 0.7470

44 Grand National Blackpool UK 132 122 42 3 0.7395

45 Thundercoaster Tusenfryd NO 57 121 44 1 0.7319

46 Giant Dipper Santa Cruz Bch Bdwk CA 128 121 46 0 0.7246

47 The Beast Kings Island OH 271 120 46 1 0.7216

48 Silver Comet Martin's Fantasy Is. NY 69 120 47 0 0.7186

49 Viper SFGAm IL 184 119 48 0 0.7126

 

50 Boardwalk Bullet Kemah Boardwalk TX 50 114 49 4 0.6946

51 Wild Mouse Blackpool UK 128 115 52 0 0.6886

52 Twister Knoebel's PA 231 114 53 0 0.6826

53 GhostRider Knott's Berry Farm CA 202 112 53 2 0.6766

 

54 Cyclone Lakeside CO 39 110 55 2 0.6647 15

55 Thunderbolt Kennywood PA 210 110 55 2 0.6647 14

56 Cyclone Luna Park NY 163 110 56 1 0.6617

57 Cyclops Mount Olympus WI 121 109 57 1 0.6557

 

58 Rutschebanen Tivoli Gardens DK 78 106 58 2 0.6446 22

59 Roar SF Discovery Kingdom CA 123 107 59 1 0.6437 14

60 Excalibur Funtown USA ME 62 106 59 2 0.6407

 

61 Loup Garou Walibi Belgium BE 86 103 61 2 0.6265

62 Jack Rabbit Kennywood PA 213 104 63 0 0.6228

63 Wild One SF America MD 174 103 63 1 0.6198

64 Yankee Cannonball Canobie Lake Park NH 77 101 64 2 0.6108

 

65 Blue Streak Cedar Point OH 334 99 67 1 0.5958 24

66 Rutschebanen Bakken DK 67 96 64 6 0.5964 23

67 The Boss Six Flags St Louis MO 125 98 67 2 0.5928

 

68 Coaster Thrill Ride Puyallup Fair WA 20 94 67 4 0.5818

 

69 Great White Wild Wheels Pier NJ 102 94 71 2 0.5689

70 Vuoristorata Linnamaki Park FI 40 92 70 4 0.5663

71 Falken Farup Sommerland DK 55 91 70 5 0.5633

72 Mammut Tripsdrill DE 84 89 70 6 0.5576

73 Cannonball Lake Winnepesaukah GA 82 89 73 5 0.5479

74 Regina Tobu Zoo JP 28 87 72 8 0.5449

75 Blue Streak Conneaut Lake Park PA 76 86 72 9 0.5419 26

76 Screamin' Eagle Six Flags St Louis MO 139 90 76 1 0.5419 16

77 Big Dipper Blackpool UK 129 88 75 4 0.5389

78 Hell Cat Clementon Lake NJ 64 86 75 6 0.5329

79 Wild Mouse Luna Park-Sydney AU 17 83 73 9 0.5303

80 Outlaw Adventureland IA 60 85 78 4 0.5210

81 Cheetah Wild Adventures GA 60 84 79 4 0.5150 22

82 Hoosier Hurricane Indiana Beach IN 136 84 79 4 0.5150 20

83 Wildcat Hersheypark PA 288 84 81 2 0.5090 27

84 Swamp Fox Family Kingdom SC 59 83 80 4 0.5090 20

85 Robin Hood Walibi Holland NL 124 82 80 4 0.5060

86 Racer Kennywood PA 212 82 82 3 0.5000

87 Giant Dipper Belmont Park CA 112 82 84 1 0.4940

88 Lost Coaster of SM Indiana Beach IN 116 80 84 3 0.4880

89 The Legend Arnolds Park IA 29 77 84 6 0.4790 5

90 Grt Am Scrm Mach SFoG GA 178 79 86 2 0.4790 12

91 Roller Coaster Lagoon UT 37 77 84 6 0.4790 4

92 Hullamvasut Vidam HU 16 72 80 10 0.4753 6

93 Georgia Cyclone SFoG GA 178 79 87 1 0.4760 5

 

94 American Eagle SFGAm IL 187 73 93 1 0.4401

 

95 Skyliner Lakemont PA 99 70 95 2 0.4251 32

96 Gwazi-Tiger Busch Gardens-Tampa FL 231 70 95 2 0.4251 30

97 Tornado Adventureland IA 63 66 92 9 0.4222

98 Roar SF America MD 176 69 97 1 0.4162

99 Comet Hersheypark PA 286 68 99 0 0.4072

100 Racer Kings Island OH 253 66 99 2 0.4012

101 Gwazi-Lion Busch Gardens-Tampa FL 237 66 100 1 0.3982

102 Jack Rabbit Seabreeze NY 73 65 101 1 0.3922

 

103 Tornado Stricker's Grove OH 58 62 103 2 0.3772

104 Arkansas Twister Magic Springs AR 27 59 101 6 0.3735

105 The Grizzly Kings Dominion VA 256 60 103 4 0.3713 10

106 White Cyclone Nagashima Spaland JP 28 57 100 9 0.3705 4

107 Timberhawk Enchanted Village WA 25 57 100 8 0.3697 1

108 Zeus Mount Olympus WI 119 60 105 2 0.3653 41

109 Rebel Yell Kings Dominion VA 262 60 105 2 0.3653 49

110 Cyclone SF New England MA 205 60 105 2 0.3653 37

111 Le Monstre La Ronde QU 72 55 103 9 0.3563

112 Elf Hirakata Park JP 13 51 101 14 0.3494

 

113 Colossus S.F. Magic Mountain CA 221 55 112 0 0.3293

114 Cannonball Waterville USA AL 23 51 109 6 0.3253

115 Thunderbolt SF New England MA 202 51 110 6 0.3234

 

116 Roller Coaster Great Yarmouth UK 41 48 112 6 0.3072

117 Wildcat Frontier City OK 39 49 114 4 0.3054

118 Judge Roy Scream SFoT TX 119 49 116 2 0.2994

119 Thunder Road Carowinds NC 158 49 117 1 0.2964

 

120 Timber Wolf Worlds of Fun MO 106 46 119 2 0.2814 22

121 Thunderhawk Dorney Park PA 239 47 120 0 0.2814 35

122 Rollo Coaster Idlewild PA 73 46 119 2 0.2814 30

123 Leap the Dips Lakemont PA 98 45 119 3 0.2784

124 Nickelodeon Streak Blackpool UK 107 45 121 1 0.2725

125 Big Dipper Camden Park WV 42 42 119 6 0.2695

126 Dragon Coaster Playland NY 84 43 122 2 0.2635

127 Stampida Port Aventura ES 125 40 121 5 0.2560

128 High Roller Valleyfair! MN 96 41 123 3 0.2545

129 Scenic Railway Luna Park-Melbourne AU 16 37 118 8 0.2515

 

130 Hochschaubahn Prater Park AT 29 31 122 11 0.2226

131 Wildcat Lake Compounce CT 158 36 130 1 0.2186

132 Kingdom Coaster Dutch Wonderland PA 70 36 131 0 0.2156

133 Wolverine Wildcat Michigan's Adventure MI 104 35 131 1 0.2126 3

134 Jupiter Kijima Korakuen JP 17 29 124 12 0.2121 3

135 Hurler Carowinds NC 157 34 133 0 0.2036

136 Comet Waldameer PA 136 32 133 2 0.1976

137 Meteor Little Amerricka WI 43 29 133 5 0.1886

138 Hurler Kings Dominion VA 254 31 136 0 0.1856 35

139 Rattler Fiesta Texas TX 88 28 133 6 0.1856 32

 

140 Coastersaurus Legoland Florida FL 52 26 138 3 0.1647

141 M.Can.Mine Buster Canada's Wonderland ON 117 27 140 0 0.1617 62

142 Wild Beast Canada's Wonderland ON 118 27 140 0 0.1617 46

143 Rolling Thunder SFGAd NJ 294 26 140 1 0.1587 21

144 Sea Dragon Jungle Jacks Landing OH 52 26 140 1 0.1587 19

 

145 Tomahawk Port Aventura ES 114 23 140 3 0.1476

146 Twister II Elitch Gardens CO 56 23 143 1 0.1407

147 Little Dipper SFGAm IL 86 22 144 1 0.1347 27

148 Pegasus Mount Olympus WI 114 21 143 3 0.1347 27

 

149 Zach's Zoomer Michigan's Adventure MI 95 18 148 1 0.1108

150 Blue Flyer Blackpool UK 100 17 148 2 0.1078

151 Predator Darien Lake NY 121 17 149 1 0.1048

152 Woodstock Express Carowinds NC 133 16 151 0 0.0958 48

153 Woodstock Express Kings Island OH 191 16 151 0 0.0958 40

154 Teddy Bear Stricker's Grove OH 55 14 152 1 0.0868

155 Ghoster Coaster Kings Dominion VA 208 14 153 0 0.0838

156 Mean Streak Cedar Point OH 337 12 154 1 0.0749

157 Underground Adventureland IA 59 10 153 4 0.0719

158 Ghoster Coaster Canada's Wonderland ON 113 11 155 1 0.0689

 

159 Magnus Colossus Terra Mitica ES 41 8 156 2 0.0542 0

160 Kiddie Coaster Playland NY 13 5 122 4 0.0534 0

161 White Canyon Yomiuriland JP 28 7 157 2 0.0482

162 Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK 31 7 158 1 0.0452

163 Antelope Gulliver's World UK 27 4 154 5 0.0399

 

164 Lil' Dipper Camden Park WV 36 3 162 2 0.0240

165 The Bandit Movie Park DE 122 3 163 1 0.0210 25

166 Coaster-Express Parque Warner Madrid ES 68 3 163 1 0.0210 17

167 The Grizzly Great America CA 122 3 164 0 0.0180

168 Anaconda Walygator Parc FR 71 2 164 0 0.0120

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wood Coaster Poll results are OUT! http://www.ushsho.com/woodrollercoasterpollresults2012.htm

 

eltoro_number1.jpg.24b517718535bcfab315ce00218d08fb.jpg

Six Flags Great Adventure's El Toro is #1!

 

Here's the top twenty:

1 El Toro SFGAd NJ 297 167 0 0 1.0000

2 T Express Everland KR 19 164 1 1 0.9910

3 The Voyage Holiday World IN 202 164 3 0 0.9820 57

4 Boulder Dash Lake Compounce CT 174 164 3 0 0.9820 52

5 Phoenix Knoebel's PA 242 163 4 0 0.9760

6 Balder Liseberg SE 86 160 5 1 0.9669

7 Dauling Dragon-L Happy Valley CN 11 155 7 3 0.9485 4

8 Ravine Flyer II Waldameer PA 145 158 8 1 0.9491 3

9 Dauling Dragon-R Happy Valley CN 11 154 8 3 0.9424

10 Colossos Heide Park DE 122 156 9 2 0.9401

11 Fireball Happy Valley Song CN 18 155 11 0 0.9337

12 El Toro Freizeitpark Plohn DE 35 153 11 1 0.9303

13 Troy Toverland NL 120 154 12 0 0.9277

14 Wood Coaster Knight Valley CN 11 146 7 10 0.9264

15 Thunderhead Dollywood TN 184 152 14 1 0.9132

16 Twister Grona Lund SE 39 149 15 2 0.9036

17 Prowler Worlds of Fun MO 88 149 16 2 0.8982

18 Thunderbird PowerPark FI 34 147 19 0 0.8855

19 Renegade Valleyfair! MN 78 147 20 0 0.8802

20 Tremors Silverwood ID 39 143 18 5 0.8765

 

And the bottom ten:

158 Ghoster Coaster Canada's Wonderland ON 113 11 155 1 0.0689

159 Magnus Colossus Terra Mitica ES 41 8 156 2 0.0542 0

160 Kiddie Coaster Playland NY 13 5 122 4 0.0534 0

161 White Canyon Yomiuriland JP 28 7 157 2 0.0482

162 Tyrolean Tubtwist Joyland UK 31 7 158 1 0.0452

163 Antelope Gulliver's World UK 27 4 154 5 0.0399

164 Lil' Dipper Camden Park WV 36 3 162 2 0.0240

165 The Bandit Movie Park DE 122 3 163 1 0.0210 25

166 Coaster-Express Parque Warner Madrid ES 68 3 163 1 0.0210 17

167 The Grizzly Great America CA 122 3 164 0 0.0180

168 Anaconda Walygator Parc FR 71 2 164 0 0.0120

 

And here's where Son of Beast would have placed if it was still open....

183 Son of Beast (SBNO) Kings Island OH 177 5 178 2 0.0324

 

Mitch says the steel poll should be coming soon!

Edited by robbalvey
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great poll, and for the most part I agree with a lot of it.

 

All Intamin and Gravity Group (CCI) coasters in the top ten (plus awesome Phoenix), GCI's in that second tier. I don't understand how GCI El Toro and Troy rank the highest of the GCI's though!?!? Not even close. Perhaps this is another example of the Europeans trying really hard to get their coasters in the top?

 

We're probably also approaching the time to take off the kiddie woodies from the poll.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great poll and glad to see El Toro still holding on at #1 & Ravine Flyer 2 holding in the Top Ten!

 

Surprised that Wild Beast and Mighty Canadian Spine Buster weren't lower than Ghoster Coaster though!

 

Edit: It will be interesting to see where Rattler ends up at this time next year. My guess is that it won't be at #139!!!!

Edited by Philrad71
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bringing it over

 

Hooray for 1# El Toro! Can't wait for the Steelie to open up

 

ADMIN EDIT: Werner, I purposely did not post the entire results as to give incentive for people to visit Mitch page. He's worked VERY hard on this poll and he deserves some support from our readers, rather than people just copy/pasting his work into our forum. Thanks for your understanding.

Edited by robbalvey
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's interesting that Voyage continues to rank as high as it does even though it seems like I've read nothing but poor reviews of how rough that thing has become the past couple of years. I would still rank it in my top 5 based on my rides from about 5 years ago (haven't been back since) but don't know if I would rate it as highly in it's current condition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great list!

A few observations:

Wooden Warrior is still in the top 25, and ranked above such venerable coasters as Raven and Shivering Timbers.

Is Gwazi Lion the lowest ranked GCI?

The Phoenix is still in the top 5 after all these years.

The "worst" new woodie built in the past 5 years is Mammut. Has never ranked above 60.

The SBNO Ozark Wildcat would still be in the top 20 today.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't really understand why anyone thinks that Boulder Dash is better than Phoenix but to each his (or her) own. Both are great coasters.

 

It's great to see El Toro at number one again. It's easily my favorite wood coaster. I don't understand why more Intamin woodies haven't popped up since they built El Toro and it's had such overwhelming success.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't really understand why anyone thinks that Boulder Dash is better than Phoenix but to each his (or her) own. Both are great coasters.

 

It's great to see El Toro at number one again. It's easily my favorite wood coaster. I don't understand why more Intamin woodies haven't popped up since they built El Toro and it's had such overwhelming success.

I agree with you on that, Intamin should be building more pre-fabs but its what the parks want, so i dont know why parks dont want them?! They are sweet

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use https://themeparkreview.com/forum/topic/116-terms-of-service-please-read/