We just got back from NYC for the first time ever (went for a concert at MSG!) but we had the entire first day we were there plus two half days to explore and well... Find and eat the best pizza the city has to offer!
So we did a bunch of research and I made a wish list of spots (which was about 6 or 7 places, but we finished with 9!). And wow, NYC did not disappoint.. The pizza was incredible, as was the city as a whole. We had a BLAST and will absolutely will be back!
As far as our favorite? That's really hard... I would just say the top 3 that stuck out in my head most... Joe's, Mama's Too and John's of Bleecker... Oh, and that pepperoni sicilian from Prince's... Yum. It is REALLY close though, they are all fantastic. I also had to get one $1 slice, just because, and you absolutely can tell it wasn't in the same league as the others... But I still liked it for what it was.
Pictures are more fun than a bunch of text, so here is just a list of all of our stops with the pics to follow:
1.) Joe's
2.) Prince Street
3.) Di Fara
4.) Mama's Too
5.) John's of Bleecker Street
6.) 99c Fresh Pizza
7.) Ben's Pizza of SoHo
8.) Scarr's
9.) Pizza Suprema
10.) Joe's (again!)